Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It depends on how you pronounce it. In the US the "h" is silent and it's pronounced "erb".


So Herbie (the car) was 'erbie? Cockney-style?


no, it was pronounced "her-bee" but herbal is pronounced "err-bul". Again, this is only for US English, not sure about UK.

A Herbie toy.

An herbal tea.


I agree that "err-bul" for herbal is quite common in the US. However, "erb" for herb is not.


It might be a regional dialect. Growing up in the west coast, I have never heard "her-bal tea", but rather always heard "er-bull tea". Hearing the "h" sound in "herb" (as I do whenever I hear British (and Australian?) speakers speak) was always very jarring, until I realized that it was just that they pronounce that class of words differently than we do.

It's possible that in the eastern or southern US, they say the H in "herb".


I'm not aware of any American dialect of English that aspirates the h in "herb."


http://www.foodnetwork.com/videos/drying-herbs-96752.html

Whew, that was easy. Next time, try some of the 100 million people living on the east coast.


I listened to that video, and did not hear any aspirated 'h's in 'herb' or 'herbal'.

Your snark is rude and uncalled-for.


This isn't universal in USA.


As far as I know, it is. We try to make French words sound French.


That would be "herbe".


What part of the US pronounces the H in herb?


I don't know that it's a regional variation, but about half of the people in my family pronounce the "h", including me most of the time. My sense is almost that dropping the "h" is an "educated" thing, and those who don't drop it are unconsciously tweaking the whole concept.


What part of the country do you live in if you don't mind me asking?

I'm just curious so that I can try to imagine the accent.

I live in the southeast, we say things like reckon, yall, and wander, but "erb" is still the accepted way to pronounce herb 'round here.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: