Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more anonfunction's commentslogin

It's super hard to tell what's actually happening. Because I've seen other reports that Iran state media halted traffic earlier today, as reported by Washington Post[1]:

> With Trump and Iran each claiming victory, but still far apart on key issues, traffic in the Strait of Hormuz remained at a standstill Wednesday.

1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2026/04/08/trump-iran-w...


That's because Israel killed hundreds of civilians in Lebanon today.

It's only hard to tell if you rely on the US billionaire controlled media.

It's been very hard to watch how many people who, a few years ago, believed everything the media said about say the pandemic, now claim you can't trust them at all. Time makes "conspiracy theorists" out of all of us -- it can be hard to see just how much the media lies and distorts, until they start talking about something you care about.

> how many people who, a few years ago, believed everything the media said about say the pandemic

Are you sure they're the same people and do you have examples of misinformation these people believed 6 years ago?


If you NOW believe that the media is corrupt and full of lies, but also believe that 6 years ago they were 100% truthful, you're being intellectually stunted. If you believed all the media lies during Covid, but NOW you see that the media is lying about the Middle East, you should have the intellectual honesty to at least earnestly consider if you were duped back then. Because that's much more likely than the entire media going from truthful to deceitful in that same period.

So "No" then?

Oh don't be so obtuse. We're not going to get into a big long debate about the particulars -- it's been done a million times, you can search the details if you actually care. But you're only asking in an attempt to deflect the topic away from the reality staring you right in your face, if you had the courage to admit it.

I really can't search the particulars if you're not saying anything specific.

Wow thanks, there's not really any dm functionality on hn and I didn't see a clear social handle in your profile. https://github.com/montanaflynn/ has my email.

You could get in touch with GP by googling for his company (see profile), finding his name through the company website (he's the CEO), and then googling for his LinkedIn/X accounts.

Also: Cool project!


What do you think of adding prediction market data to the indication? So basically there's this:

https://polymarket.com/event/strait-of-hormuz-traffic-return...

My approach would be if that jumps up to 75%+ it would change to YES. And if we get into May they have one for then too:

https://polymarket.com/event/strait-of-hormuz-traffic-return...

You can actually see in the last 24 hours it jumped up with the ceasefire and Iran saying they would open it and fell back with reports it's been shut down again easlier today.

Edit: I added this, I can see a few downvotes, happy to discuss here or in the github repo if anyone has strong feelings on it!


i didnt downvote you but why wouldn't i just go to Polymarket directly for this

I mean you obviously could, the url is a little harder to remember and it doesn't have crossing data. This was just a small fun project I did, so you're free to do whatever you like. The reason I thought of using polymarket data is I didn't have live ship tracking data which is what I originally intended to use.

I don't mean to say your project is not good, quite the opposite. You successfully got the real vessel crossing data and the prediction data is sort of derived or not really based on reality but on the crowd.

Funnily enough, I did find a few satellite sources at the beginning for the map background and noticed that all the ships seemed to be scrubbed from the image. It's an interesting idea, thanks for the comment!

The sources I used were:

- ESRI World Imagery[1] — free satellite tiles, high-res, but ships are stripped out from the imagery

- NASA GIBS - VIIRS[2] — near real-time daily satellite imagery from NASA, but resolution is ~375m so ships aren't visible anyway

- Mapbox Satellite[3] — high-res and looks great, but same deal — ships are scrubbed from the composited imagery

1. https://server.arcgisonline.com/ArcGIS/rest/services/World_I... 2. https://earthdata.nasa.gov/engage/open-data-services-softwar... 3. https://www.mapbox.com


Ai2 has vessel detection models for Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 (ESA) along with Landsat 8, Landsat 9, and VIIRS Nighttime Lights (NASA/USGS/NOAA):

- Sentinel-2 (10 m/pixel): https://github.com/allenai/rslearn_projects/blob/master/docs...

- Landsat (15-30 m/pixel): https://github.com/allenai/rslearn_projects/blob/master/docs...

- VIIRS Nighttime Lights: https://github.com/allenai/vessel-detection-viirs

I think you can see these vessel detections at https://app.skylight.earth/ ("Try out a limited version as a guest") but they seem to be delayed by 48 hours.

VIIRS is very low resolution but you can make out vessels with reasonable accuracy in the night-time images.

VIIRS covers most locations at least once per day, but the other sensors capture a given location only once per 5-10 days (although when combined, Sentinel-1/Sentinel-2/Landsat should provide close-to-daily coverage).


There is also a lot of jamming, manipulating, and fake AIS broadcasting going on

https://windward.ai/blog/gps-jamming-disrupts-1100-ships-in-...


It turns out during a war having real time satellite imagery of shipping would be a poor choice.

but what about other experiments, just saying, it's subjective

you could, presumably, mess up other instruments than visual to interfere with enemy countries


"Nice crop watering prediction model you have there, shame if someone modified source data and your crops would falter..."

grim times

and you just know governments will do supply chain style attacks.

Crypto AG cia front company, encryption devices

backdoor in RSA key generation by nsa

exploding pagers

usa installing bugs in enterprise router exports


modifying the data is crazy

doesn't this sort of thing invalidate any kind of experiment because the instrument is no longer trustworthy


Most of them remove clouds for similar reasons - moving/temporary stuff in individual images makes the underlying data useless.

Totally agree, I put some text and tried to make it clear. My first intention was to find some live ship tracking API and see how many ships cross the strait, but they were all hundreds of dollars a month, and behind enterprise contact forms.

You need to send an analyst there with binoculars, a box of cigars and $15k in cash to get realtime trustworthy data

The strait is wider than horizon distance from reasonable heights. Also that's how you don't hear back from the analyst in many different ways.

Do these ships not use transponders? E.g., in the US you can use a SDR dongle and a RPI to read local updates. The straight isn't very wide.

Seems cheaper than the cigars and cash.


Transponders get turned off all the time, especially if you don't want to be targeted.

Are they though, in the straight ? I'm not sure it's such a great move, TBH:

Given that the baddies clearly can locate ships and see that there's no transponder, and come to the conclusion they need. "Hmm, it turned off transponders and is now moving toward the straight. It's a tanker, and not one of ours, or Russia's or China's. Let's bomb it!"

Also, pragmatically, you could look at the transponders suddenly not showing up anymore as a sign of attempt of passage, especially if they show up later on the other side.

But yes, that would no longer be very realtime.


The fleet serving Iran and Russia does not use transponders. It's a large fleet. Ships without transponders are just a fact of life in shipping.

Sure, but for the purpose of this discussion, those ships don't matter. What matters is what the ships NOT belonging to Iran's friends do.

Technically all ships crossing the strait matter as their cargos end up being bought, sanctioned or not, Iran-friendly or not; they wouldn't have crossed otherwise. If we're talking about avoiding a global recession and worst case famine in some parts of the world, the oil and gas must start moving regardless of who is the shipowner.

Transponders are a voluntary system, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_fleet

or just a cubesat on a polar orbit with a Nikon Z9 inside

I've done some small scale ship tracking in the past, and yeah, anything beyond finding a specific ship while it is near the shore is stupid expensive.

Totally, and I've heard a lot of it comes down to insurance!

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-04-08/shippers-...


Yeah! The AIS terrain data is expensive, but the good stuff is from satellite tracking and out of my budget for silly site I built on a whim.

https://i.imgflip.com/aopmmf.jpg


Another funny thing about this was this morning I checked if the domain isthestraitofhormuzopenyet.com was available and it was, and by the time I made the site locally, put it on vercel I went to buy the domain to point DNS to it someone had bought it! I renamed it to the current site url / repo which i think might be a little nicer to type, but crazy that we had same idea on apparently the same day. I was also just telling a friend about simultaneous invention aka multiple discover[1] a few days ago, so another case of the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon[2]!

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency_illusion


I was also surprised to see that arewegreatyet.com is in use already...

CartoDB and Leaflet. Source is available here btw: https://github.com/montanaflynn/ishormuzopenyet

As an OpenStreetMap-contributor: you have to add attribution as per our license agreement: https://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright

CartoDB packages this data into tiles you can use, but that doesn't lift this requirement.


Thank you for this comment, I just fixed it[1], don't know why claude code decided to hide it, I actually should have known this requirement and checked!

1. https://github.com/montanaflynn/ishormuzopenyet/commit/70a8c...


I was implementing OSM the other day (with attribution of course) and noticed Carto seemed to be one of the only players with good dark tiles.

Seems like we can't use them for free, even with attribution, unless I get a grant?


I shorm uzo pen yet also!

Great point and something I didn't consider, I should make a big disclaimer it's not meant to be fully accurate or live data. Thanks for the comment!

not to discredit what you've built though, good work!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: