Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | akomtu's commentslogin

"Hand writing" your own thoughts is the only true way, though. If some entity does your thinking, then it's no longer you.

Yes, now that's a reasoned though on how AI will affect us, but fortunately - the AI is not 'doing our thinking for us' any more that 'calculators did', and, that's not going to stop us from using AI.

People not using AI will be about as useful as those refusing to use e-mail or computers.

It's absurd.


Doing our thinking for us is the purpose of AI, isn't it? It's called artificial intelligence for a reason.

AI is a broad term and ML aglos for playing chess fall under that since the 1920s.

AI may replace some cognitive activity, it also required cognitive intelligence to use 'slide rules' - which have been replaced and we have not looked bad.

It's not a bad rhetorical question - but it's moot in the face of the question of 'should we use it or not'.

It will do a lot of things for us - that part is inevitable and unavoidable.

We'll have plenty to think about.


If the crowd is running towards a cliff, I'd rather be left behind.

This is the only advice.

It’s gonna be painful and many firms will go bust - not because of being left behind. But they got so deep in pushing llm’s their competitors came in and offered their customers what they wanted - the customers don’t care how you produce it. They want the thing to that leaves them in the best economical state. And this llm mania is gonna cause many firms to forget this and go down paths they will later regret.


Because it's their creation.

I don't know if that is sarcasm, but a chair I buy is mine to do whatever I want with it. Same goes for clothes, a mattress, paint, or any other non-software enabled physical item. Why does having software/hardware make a difference?

Because your clothes and paint do not need security updates, since they do not talk to the internet. Your mattress cannot be made part of a botnet.

Somehow my computer has not become part of a botnet despite having a free OS.

A quite large chunk of botnet "members" are IoT crap (even mattresses).

Tell that to my eightSleep mattress

You can do whatever you want with your phone too, it isn’t illegal to jailbreak an iPhone for example.

That scene is dying a boiling-frog death. The newest OS that is fully jailbreakable on a sufficiently-modern arm64e device is 16.5.1 (go back a few models to the iPhone X and the current Dopamine beta works up to 16.7.15). There is also a "semi-jailbreak" called nathanlr, which is less full featured and works up to iOS 17.0 on iPhone 15 and prior. There's also TrollStore which isn't a jailbreak, but allows unlimited sideloading with arbitrary entitlements. This tool only functions on the following versions of iOS: 14.0 beta 2 - 16.6.1, 16.7 RC (20H18), 17.0

These OS versions are getting long in the tooth, and apps are already starting to drop support for them.


Because capitalists extend control wherever they can to maximize profitability.

If you want decisions that corporations make to be aligned with the desires of their users, you should be advocating for software/hardware built by consumer cooperatives.


Then think about all sorts of rulers and dictators who will ask AI "I've got this problem with the populace. I'd like to see it gone. What do I do?"

AI is making you more like a machine, IMO.

2046: The planetary AI brags it spends more natural resources on machines than it spends on humans.

2126: AI brags that it's reached 100% efficiency in Earth utilization after it's eliminated all organic life.


Other AIs are laughing at this flex as their Dyson sphere projects are already set into motion.

Is it a coincidence that the diameter of Earth orbit is 1000 light seconds, or that our Moon perfectly eclipses Sun? The Pyramid is a comparatively modest example.

Technology has caused this. Once a society becomes highly developed, it fuses itself with technology that eventually replaces human culture with efficiency, productivity and similar crap.

With LLMs, materialists have got a silicone idol to worship. They believe that they know everything about this idol because they've created it, and at the same time they believe that LLMs have a secret sauce that makes it intelligent. Looking at how they are trying to extract intelligence from it reminds me of alchemists of the past who tried to extract gold from lead.


AI is turning into a religion for materialists.


Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: